Y Hacker News Books
Buy on Amazon4.6 out of 5, 187 ratings on Amazon

#30 of 2,629 all-time

Calculus

Spivak

99 people recommended it in 33 threads, 2009–2026.

2 of those were in the last year.

1 commenter pushed back on it — worth reading the threads.

What people on Hacker News said

jwgarber
The canonical text for this topic is Calculus by Michael Spivak. It's what I used in my first year, and most importantly, comes with a solution manual :)

on HN, 2019

mrbrowning
Reading Spivak's Calculus, with the way that it starts off its path of inquiry by showing that, beginning with the basis of a totally-ordered field, the axioms at hand don't suffice to demonstrate the existence of e.g. a number that satisfies x^2 = 2, made me feel right at home again.

on HN, 2019

jsenn
Calculus by Spivak. This was used in my intro calculus course in university. It's very much a bottom-up, first-principles construction of calculus. Very proof-based, so you have to be into that. Tons of exercises, including some that sneakily introduce pretty advanced concepts not explicitly covered in the main text. This book, along with the course, rearranged by brain.

on HN, 2023

throwawaymath
This gives you a rigorous treatment of calculus, which hopefully you have some familiarity with. After this you can move on to real analysis.

on HN, 2019

solinent
However, I personally would never learn it this way--I prefer Spivak, during my read through I learned more than I could ever learn in a class.

on HN, 2020

jacobolus
Spivak’s Calculus is an introductory real analysis book pitched at undergraduates who have gone through a computational calculus course already and want to study the subject more formally and rigorously; it has many difficult problems and would generally benefit greatly from the structure and expert feedback of a university course.

on HN, 2018

And on Amazon

A gift from Spivak: beautifully clear writing that may make you fall in love with math

The prose in this book is perhaps the best writing on a technical subject I have ever seen. Calculus--a dry, boring, and mechanical subject for most other authors--is here presented as a beautiful and interesting intellectual achievement worthy of study on its own right. Even if you aren't a math for math's sake sort of person, it is always worthy of attention when an expert like Spivak explains what their world is like with such clarity and passion. And if any book may convince you that the people who say "math is beautiful" aren't nuts, it's this one. …

jy · verified purchase · 5/5

Absolutely love it

This book is widely considered the absolute best book to learn Calculus, and it's very obvious why. I'm trying to re-learn Calculus, as it's been about 12 years since I studied it in University and I haven't had to use it since. The book came beautifully packaged and the condition is absolutely perfect. 10/10

Kenneth Dolbow · verified purchase · 5/5

A key to open upper level math courses

The Calculus fourth edition by Spivak sat on my desk for a while. When I first purchased it, I tried some of the beginning problems, then I felt that they were a little more rigorous and abstract, meaning more mastery of mathematics for me to do before I can do the exercises. So, there it remained for a couple of years. Until suddenly a few weeks ago, when I was working in Lebesgue Integration, that I needed to bridge the gap from Calculus to Analysis to Integration and Measure theory. …

Tri D. Atran · verified purchase · 5/5

Where it comes up