Calculus
Spivak
99 people recommended it in 33 threads, 2009–2026.
2 of those were in the last year.
1 commenter pushed back on it — worth reading the threads.
What people on Hacker News said
The canonical text for this topic is Calculus by Michael Spivak. It's what I used in my first year, and most importantly, comes with a solution manual :)
Reading Spivak's Calculus, with the way that it starts off its path of inquiry by showing that, beginning with the basis of a totally-ordered field, the axioms at hand don't suffice to demonstrate the existence of e.g. a number that satisfies x^2 = 2, made me feel right at home again.
Calculus by Spivak. This was used in my intro calculus course in university. It's very much a bottom-up, first-principles construction of calculus. Very proof-based, so you have to be into that. Tons of exercises, including some that sneakily introduce pretty advanced concepts not explicitly covered in the main text. This book, along with the course, rearranged by brain.
This gives you a rigorous treatment of calculus, which hopefully you have some familiarity with. After this you can move on to real analysis.
However, I personally would never learn it this way--I prefer Spivak, during my read through I learned more than I could ever learn in a class.
Spivak’s Calculus is an introductory real analysis book pitched at undergraduates who have gone through a computational calculus course already and want to study the subject more formally and rigorously; it has many difficult problems and would generally benefit greatly from the structure and expert feedback of a university course.
Where it comes up
- Ask HN: What, in your opinion, are the greatest and most useful textbooks? 2020 · 15 recommendations
- Ask HN: Are there books for mathematics like Feynman's lectures on physics? 2019 · 11 recommendations
- Ask HN: Recommend a maths book for a teenager? 2020 · 9 recommendations
- Ask HN: Math books that made you significantly better at math? 2023 · 7 recommendations
- Ask HN: The book that did it for you in math and/or CS? 2022 · 6 recommendations
- Book: Mathematics for Machine Learning 2018 · 5 recommendations
- The Best Textbooks on Every Subject 2018 · 3 recommendations
- Programming books you might want to consider reading 2016 · 3 recommendations
- Textbooks must die 2009 · 3 recommendations
- Show HN: Free textbook on engineering thermodynamics 2026 · 2 recommendations
- How to choose a textbook that is optimal for oneself? 2024 · 2 recommendations
- Ask HN: What are the most eye-opening textbooks you have ever read? 2023 · 2 recommendations
- Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topic finally click? 2022 · 2 recommendations
- Show HN: 40k HN comments mentioning books, extracted using deep learning 2021 · 2 recommendations
- The Textbook That Unleashed Ramanujan's Genius 2021 · 2 recommendations
- Free Linear Algebra textbook 2020 · 2 recommendations
- Free and Open-Source Mathematics Textbooks 2019 · 2 recommendations
- Ask HN: Mathematicians, what textbooks are best for learning these math topics? 2019 · 2 recommendations
- U.S. Congress Renews $5M Open Textbook Pilot for Second Year 2018 · 2 recommendations
- Why Are College Textbooks So Absurdly Expensive? 2013 · 2 recommendations
