Y Hacker News Books
Buy on Amazon4.6 out of 5, 2,289 ratings on Amazon

#120 of 2,629 all-time

Debt: The First 5000 Years

David Graeber

41 people recommended it in 24 threads, 2011–2024.

13 commenters pushed back on it — worth reading the threads.

What people on Hacker News said

sinkpoint
"Debt: The first 5000 years" completely changed the way I view money, society, and relationships.

on HN, 2019

hypersoar
Even if you aren't onboard with Graeber's radical left politics, both books are so chock full of ideas and examples that it's hard to come away without a lot to think about.

on HN, 2022

contingencies
It cops a lot of flak from some conservative established economists though, probably because most of the book is dedicated to disassembling economic myth from the perspective of history and anthropology.

on HN, 2016

kbob
History of economic systems. Everything we know about money is one of many alternatives tried somewhere at some time.

on HN, 2015

profEpcot
Bit of a slog, but worth it for an in depth look at the historic mechanisms of debt that are inexorably tied to violence and control

on HN, 2015

pauljonas
Anthropologist shreds sacred classical "economics" cows on markets, debt, capitalism, etc.… …hard not to see things after taking in this fantastic research.

on HN, 2011

vishnugupta
This is truly a magnum opus. Until I read this I had taken money, economy, market etc., for granted. And I had held onto the widely accepted, but naive, view that economic systems somehow grew out of barter systems.

on HN, 2019

And on Amazon

Detailed and Fascinating Economic History--Every Single Page Highly Enjoyable

Graeber's book is a long, slow read, yet it is a fascinating page-turner for which I enjoyed EVERY SINGLE PAGE. I would highly recommend this five-star book to anyone who enjoys investigating the mysteries of economics in our modern world and to anyone who enjoys history, sociology, anthropology, or looking for major historical trends which tie together and explain world events. I saw a few critical reviews while reading this book, and now that I have finished, my opinion is that anyone who negatively reviews this book only read a portion of it. …

Imperial Topaz · verified purchase · 5/5

Another fun and fascinating Myth-buster from David Graeber

This book came into my home because I was still high and happy on the full-on trip of reading 'The Dawn of Everything' by David Graeber and David Wengrow. That book radically re-organizes our (totally, provably, embarrassingly wrong) ideas about human history, to ask questions like 'how did we get stuck with governments. My type-a deal all the way. This book is equally interesting, and similar in many ways. The title conveys matte-dull economics blather, but (a little unlike 'capital in the twenty-first century' by Thomas Picketty, who wrote the intro to the updated edition) this book is no snoozer. It's engaging and irreverent, and funny. …

Todd · verified purchase · 5/5

Brilliant anthropological examination

Certainly my favorite book I've read this year. It must be said off the bat that it's amazing how dated (or maybe, incomplete?) the final chapter of the book feels now that 10 years have passed since it's original publication. At the time. Graeber's association with Occupy Wall Street would have been relevant; now Occupy has become so irrelevant it basically never existed. …

Nick · verified purchase · 4/5

Where it comes up