Y Hacker News Books
Buy on Amazon4.5 out of 5, 14,634 ratings on Amazon

#39 of 2,629 all-time

Guns, Germs, and Steel

Jared Diamond

83 people recommended it in 44 threads, 2007–2024.

15 commenters pushed back on it — worth reading the threads.

What people on Hacker News said

LyndsySimon
The idea that external factors like geographical starting conditions can have a huge impact and shape things as complex as human culture is a powerful one, regardless of the conclusions drawn in the book.

on HN, 2019

autodidacticon
Civilizations' success can be considered a function of base resources (edible grains, farmland, metals).

on HN, 2019

Shorel
If you want a good view of the matter, please read Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies by Jared Diamond.

on HN, 2014

richardw
So many types of thinking and areas of science that I wasn't aware of. Not every part of it has to be correct for it to be incredibly interesting.

on HN, 2019

mooreds
I have a soft spot for food so especially loved the caloric analysis (the sweet potato was a game changer, IIRC).

on HN, 2021

btkramer9
I'm continually evaluating how much things are a result of my own work vs just a byproduct of the environment I'm in.

on HN, 2019

And on Amazon

One of my favorite books and the inspiration for my World Regional Geography courses that I teach.

Two decades ago when I served in the Missouri National Guard we had an extended drill weekend at Ft. Leonard Wood for a live fire artillery exercise. This was a three day drill and I remember it clearly because it was the same weekend as Princess Diana’s funeral on September 6, 1997. I had been at the local library the day before we rolled out and saw an interesting book that promised to explain why western civilization had been the one to colonize the New World and rise to ascendency over much of the world for a long period of time. That had always been an interesting question for me and one which many people do not know the answer to. …

gloine36 · verified purchase · 5/5

Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies

Recently, I finished this great, broad, historical, and significant endeavor. Let me begin by expressing my appreciation of Jared Diamond’s wonderful ability to simplify a very complex topic and related ideas. This alone, makes this read a great one. Too, there a few gems of humor and wit within the pages which caught my eye and mind. Don’t get me wrong though. The pages are filled with complex data, examples, and comparisons. Upon more than one occasion, my understanding necessitated the rereading of paragraphs and pages. …

Zachary Ruesch · verified purchase · 5/5

An impressive book with a convincing theory, but missing points

The author mainly argues that societies developed differently on different continents because of advantages in geography, not advantages in human biology. In the book, we can conclude that there are four reasons to account for all historical development. Firstly, it is the number of the crops and animals to be domesticated. The second reason is the speed of agriculture development in the continents. The next reason is the knowledge communication between different continents. The forth reason is the size of population. Diamond argues that all of four factors have convincing evidences. …

Wei Zhang · verified purchase · 4/5

Where it comes up