Y Hacker News Books
Le Ton Beau de Marot

#908 of 2,654 all-time

Le Ton Beau de Marot

Douglas Hofstadter

7 people recommended it in 7 threads, 2014–2024.

What people on Hacker News said

schlagetown
Le Ton beau de Marot, by Douglas Hofstadter - remarkable exploration of language and translation, in all its magic and complexity…both deeply personal and deeply researched, a must-read for lovers of language

on HN, 2017

sriku
Was blown by his description of how making the typographical choice of starting the first word of each chapter with letters decreasing in height to the normal page font size, caused him to rethink a whole chapter (he couldn't use descenders, which limits the first word, which limits his first sentence, which constrains his first paragraph and so on).

on HN, 2015

stenl
If you want something less theoretical, more personal, poetic and emotional, his "Le ton beau de Marot" (English, despite the title) is also fabulous. He takes a short poem and translates it a hundred different ways, all the while musing about what "translation" means (literal, conveying the same emotion, using the same metaphors, between cultures...) as well as about thought, language and meaning more generally.

on HN, 2015

stenl
And then, while he writes the book, his wife gets a brain tumor and dies, and the book becomes part of his mourning.

on HN, 2015

zem
I also liked "le ton beau de marot", on the art of translation, but that's less of a general appeal book.

on HN, 2019

cursork
Also by Hofstadter: Le Ton beau de Marot was a good read.

on HN, 2014

Where it comes up