Y Hacker News Books
Buy on Amazon4.7 out of 5, 742 ratings on Amazon

#2 of 2,629 all-time

Structure and Interpretation of Computer Programs

Harold Abelson

316 people recommended it in 122 threads, 2007–2026.

3 of those were in the last year.

25 commenters pushed back on it — worth reading the threads.

What people on Hacker News said

nikcub
Even though I had worked through SICP I still watched all the lectures again and implemented all the examples with benchmarks and unit tests.

on HN, 2011

spacemanaki
There's over 200 pages before they even introduce mutation and impure functions. Later they touch on the thorny problems that mutation creates when they touch on concurrent programming.

on HN, 2011

JackMorgan
This book helped me think about how programs run, how state is stored, how you can build out asynchronous computation, and how you can build your own languages.

on HN, 2022

ThrustVectoring
This is a bit unorthodox, but I personally got a lot out of taking the LISP code in Structure and Interpretation of Computer Programs, and mentally translating the examples and solving the exercises in Javascript.

on HN, 2017

PeterWhittaker
SICP, JS edition (great read, I do a lot of JS work and I’ve learned a lot, despite time spent studying the language itself, and I’m still in the first chapter)

on HN, 2022

And on Amazon

The Art of Generalization.. TOUGH but possibly worth it

Inductive reasoning aims at simplifying functions just enough to make them general. Simple does NOT equal easy! When Functional Programming (and its predecessors-- combinatory logic (1925) and lambda calculus (1930)) were first invented, they were aimed at clarifying mathematical logic. This "holding variables constant" or binding or eliminating them for "pure" (mathematical) functions, has been extended to Functional Programming, initially to better understand what programming is in general, then to evaluate mathematical functions while avoiding some of the complicating factors (side effects) of imperative/procedural programming. …

Professor dot biz · verified purchase · 5/5

Computer Science...Art?

You need it, too. I won't pretend to have more useful insight into the art and craft of programming, or into SICP's relationship to it, than Paul Graham or Peter Norvig- if you want to know which reviews to trust, look these cats up. The discussion in the reviews usually concludes that this is the book that separates the computer scientists from the mere programmers. There is a definite logic to this. …

B. Dean · verified purchase · 5/5

The best programming book ever, if you're a certain kind of person

This was the book that made me want to be a computer programmer. When I read it, I had no knowledge of programming beyond a little Pascal, and rudiments of C. It had a massive impact on me. It consumed me, to the point where I had difficulty finishing assignments for my classes (I did not study CS as an undergrad). What the book does is give you a vocabulary and knowledge about programming that is hard to find anywhere else. …

Jaime Silvela · verified purchase · 5/5

Where it comes up