Y Hacker News Books
Buy on Amazon4.4 out of 5, 3,359 ratings on Amazon

#51 of 2,629 all-time

The Brothers Karamazov

Fyodor Dostoevsky

69 people recommended it in 34 threads, 2009–2024.

2 commenters pushed back on it — worth reading the threads.

What people on Hacker News said

mikhmha
And of course, the book finally convinced me that I should not give into nihilism and pessimism even when everyone around me does.

on HN, 2024

ziotom78
Nowhere I found such a great depth and insight into the nature of human freedom, and the reading questioned many beliefs I had at the time about human nature and the meaning of life.

on HN, 2019

jcranberry
It implanted the idea that people, all people can be understood explicitly, through empathy (and that all people can be empathized with).

on HN, 2019

creature_x
On a side note, you'll get along well with Doestevesky's Brothers Karamazov if you found N&G affecting.

on HN, 2024

bratwurst3000
An excellent book with a deeply human and philosophical viewpoint.

on HN, 2021

And on Amazon

Complex and brilliant

This novel was long, philosophical, and complex--and absolutely worth the amount of time I spent reading it. It turned out to be far more than just a mystery of who killed Fyodor, the morally debauched Karamazov patriarch. The Brothers Karamazov is also an intense character study, a love story, and--above all--a novel of ideas. Those who have read Dostoevsky's other works will see some familiar themes in this novel--themes of redemption, guilt, and suffering, as well as what drives people to heinous crimes such as murder. Religious questions are also explored in-depth, such as the existence of God and the ultimate source of morality. …

LongLiveLibraries245 · verified purchase · 5/5

The Kindle edition I've just read is pretty badly formatted

The Kindle edition I've just read is pretty badly formatted, with frequent missing or misplaced quotation marks, some typos, and a lot of bad paragraphing. Dostoyevsky transcends it all, of course. What can anyone say that's new about it? …

M. F. Crowl · verified purchase · 5/5

Unique combination of philosophy and drama

I read this book in my early 20s at the insistence of a friend (who I later married) and was quite impressed. By age 60, my son was raving about the book, so a second person begged me to read it (again). I couldn’t remember anything about the book except that I was impressed (and one snippet from a speech by the atheist character Ivan). I am an atheist. So I read the book, which is part murder mystery, and everything was a surprise to me. The book gets off to a slow start but gets rolling about 10% of the way through. …

Ann Norman · verified purchase · 4/5

Where it comes up