Y Hacker News Books
Buy on Amazon4.7 out of 5, 416 ratings on Amazon

#65 of 2,629 all-time

The Elements of Computing Systems

Nisan and Schocken

58 people recommended it in 24 threads, 2011–2023.

What people on Hacker News said

Delfino
Even though I studied Computer Science in University and most of the concepts weren't new to me, it was such a fun experience mentally "building" a computer from relays/transistors to logic gates and up to assemblers, compilers, and interpreters.

on HN, 2019

gmiller123456
It's a course that starts with just nand gates, and leads you through the development of higher level logic gates, then an ALU, then a CPU, the an assembler, then a high level language compiler, and finally an operating system.

on HN, 2017

jdreaver
Easily one of the most interesting and engaging textbooks I've read in my entire life.

on HN, 2023

indigochill
The course really drove home for me the power of simple, well-designed layers in building complex systems, since the end goal of building a CPU from scratch sounded impossibly intimidating at the start but by the end I was comfortable in explaining every detail.

on HN, 2022

simoch
Accompanies www.nand2tetris.org and leads you through implementing logic gates, a CPU, Assembler, right up to a functional computer, with the help of simulator software on a PC.

on HN, 2016

DubiousPusher
Basically it has you hands on work through the basics of every concept active in a modern computer save for networks and web.

on HN, 2017

modzel1990
It is a long book but you will build each element of the computer if you follow it. It might not reflect nowadays computers, but surely it will bring an idea how everything works, from the very ground of gates and bits to the kernel, compiling and so on... just my personal opinion.

on HN, 2019

robto
Starting at logic gates and moving up through the levels of abstraction until you can build a programming language and implement a video game is the most fundamental approach that I'm aware of.

on HN, 2019

And on Amazon

Thrilling although kind of falls apart at the end, but still well worth the experience

This book is an unparalleled companion in explaining, piece-by-piece, how you can build a somewhat realistic computer from the ground up in a way that is tremendously satisfying. However, it does kind of fall apart at the end, and it's difficult to finish without outside resources. Still, as a concise guide, it is unparalleled, and I am extremely happy I went on this journey, even if it kind of runs out of steam at the end. This book is simply a guide to the project on the website of the same name. Completing the project is the primary intellectual profit of this book. …

Ryan O. · verified purchase · 5/5

Excellent Textbook for Self-Starters

I wanted to learn some programming languages and concepts to make my Technical Writer resume meatier. Problem was, any attempt to learn Python, SOAP, or MySQL just lead me to ask a million questions about how this stuff actually worked beneath the straightforward, high-level application stack: How does this code interact with the OS? How do lines of text get turned into binary instructions? How does all this abstract graphics, text, and data actually meet up with electrical signals and semiconductors? It has to at some point, right? It's not magic, right? (And so on). …

Peter Gambrill · verified purchase · 5/5

Outstanding survey

When I say "survey," I mean a wide-ranging view of what goes into a computing system. This unique book goes into more depth than the word suggests, though, since it presents every level as a project for the student to carry out. This starts with the processor: the authors present an elegant but very stripped-down instruction set, slightly reminiscent of the PDP-8, and an equally stripped-down hardware description language (HDL). The exercise is to implement that processor using that HDL, and verify it using a simulator the authors provide. …

wiredweird · verified purchase · 5/5

Where it comes up