Y Hacker News Books
Buy on Amazon4.4 out of 5, 3,710 ratings on Amazon

#117 of 2,629 all-time

War and Peace

Leo Tolstoy

41 people recommended it in 28 threads, 2009–2025.

1 commenter pushed back on it — worth reading the threads.

What people on Hacker News said

agigao
War and Peace is a book that will raise the bar for fiction, I couldn’t start a new one for a month after finishing it, tried but I was still living in the book.

on HN, 2022

ideonexus
What I loved most about the book was how it conveys the complexity of life and the absurdity of historical analysis and the focus on "Great Men" against such complexity, which he compares to physicists trying to understand macro-phenomenon without taking into account the micro-phenomenon that add up to the macro effect.

on HN, 2017

cetahfh14615
War and Peace: There's just has so much life in this book. The things you read, they age with you over time.

on HN, 2022

jesusofsuburbia
It made me aware that someone as successful and powerful as Napoleon himself was by a large extent only a product of the people and the mood at the time. What I mean is that it wasn't him who inspired the people; it rather was just the Zeitgeist he was the perfect person for.

on HN, 2019

sramsay
War and Peace came immediately to mind for me as well, but mostly because I do not think I have ever read a more magnificent novel.

on HN, 2019

klik99
I like slow burns of stories, and was riveted by War and Peace just as much as the show Midnight Mass.

on HN, 2025

And on Amazon

Tough, but worth it

What can I say that hasn't been said already about this classic? I guess the only thing that would be to say it's the Game of Thrones of the 19th Century. It's the Breaking Bad or Downton Abbey or Walking Dead or whatever you think is this month's MUST WATCH TV DRAMA, that's what this was for 19th Century Russian audiences. War and Peace is a huge, epic historical soap opera, with intense battles and royal intrigues and historical insight and if you can read it and not be blown away then you're not paying attention. It doesn't have it's reputation simply for being one of the longest novels ever published; it's actually that good. …

NyQuil012 · verified purchase · 5/5

Translation Matters

I have read several versions of War and Peace. If the Maude translation were half as good as it is, it would be the TWO best versions I had ever read of this masterpiece. Published in 1869, this great saga works on many levels. It is an intimate snapshot of the cultured classes of Tsarist Russia around the time of Napoleon's ill-fated invasion: glittering, provincial, backbiting and sublime all at the same time. It is a study of the fog of war, the clash of ambition, the lust for promotion, and the petty, toxic vanity of those who prefer to be in charge of a loss than a mere part of a victory. …

Meeker Pilgrim · verified purchase · 5/5

Tolstoy's epic is well worth your time & attention

An excellent book and a worthy read. This was my first Tolstoy and I found it very readable. The voices of the characters are clear and relatable. As opposed to Dostoyevsky, where you always feel like the characters are drunk and shouting at you. Unlike Dostoyevsky, Tolstoy stays mostly with the aristocracy, which is fascinating but not as well rounded. But within that privileged circle, you fully experience the harsh realities of the war and all the tragedies that it causes. Losing a child, losing a fortune, losing your reputation and the respect of your peers. …

Riki Jacobsen · verified purchase · 4/5

Where it comes up